diff --git a/app/Http/Controllers/Agent/helpdesk/Filter/FilterController.php b/app/Http/Controllers/Agent/helpdesk/Filter/FilterController.php
index 4b6ba59ed..6a525c489 100644
--- a/app/Http/Controllers/Agent/helpdesk/Filter/FilterController.php
+++ b/app/Http/Controllers/Agent/helpdesk/Filter/FilterController.php
@@ -255,17 +255,17 @@ class FilterController extends Controller
                         'u1.user_name as assign_user_name',
                         \DB::raw('max(ticket_thread.updated_at) as updated_at'),
                         \DB::raw('min(ticket_thread.updated_at) as created_at'),
-                        'tickets.priority_id', 'tickets.assigned_to',
-                        DB::raw('COUNT(ticket_thread.updated_at) as countthread'),
-                        'ticket_priority.priority_color',
-                        'u.first_name as first_name',
+                        'u.first_name as first_name',                        
                         'u.last_name as last_name',
                         'u1.first_name as assign_first_name',
                         'u1.last_name as assign_last_name',
-                        'tickets.status',
-                        'tickets.user_id',
+                        'ticket_priority.priority_color',
+                        DB::raw('COUNT(DISTINCT ticket_thread2.id) as countthread'),
                         DB::raw('COUNT(ticket_attachment.thread_id) as countattachment'),
                         DB::raw('COUNT(ticket_collaborator.ticket_id) as countcollaborator'),
+                        'tickets.status',
+                        'tickets.user_id',
+                        'tickets.priority_id', 'tickets.assigned_to',
                         'ticket_status.name as tickets_status',
                         'ticket_source.css_class as css',
                         DB::raw('substring_index(group_concat(ticket_thread.poster order by ticket_thread.id desc) , ",", 1) as last_replier'),